The Sociology of Entrepreneurship

Sociology 159 Spring 2000
MW 5:30-6:45 room W9.130

© Copyrighted material to be used for course purposes only

Patricia H. Thornton
Office Hours: MW 3:30-4:30 & by appointment
Soc-Psych Building rm. 265
Telephone: 660-5760
E-mail: thornton@soc.duke.edu
Teaching Assistant: Carmen Weigelt
Office Hours: TH 9-11:00 & by appointment
Building: Fuqua School of Business rm. 283E
Telephone: 660-7901
E-mail: cbw4@mail.duke.edu


Course Description

The goal of this course is to provide students with a survey of intellectual thought on the subject of entrepreneurship. Knowledge and application of theory are emphasized. This course considers the historical origins and current causes of entrepreneurship. The primary emphases are sociological, although entrepreneurial actors and activities are examined from psychological, political, and economic perspectives. Entrepreneurship is considered from a supply side (personal, social, and cultural) characteristics of entrepreneurs, and a demand side perspective, the (organizational, economic, and societal) conditions that give rise to new enterprise. The course reviews entrepreneurship from various levels of analysis: the individual, organizational, industrial, organizational field, and global levels. We explore how, when, and where new businesses are likely to form and what affects their relative chance of success. The final section of the course considers the topic of organizational behavior, organizational change, and how to create an effective organization. Class sessions take the form of lectures, discussions, video, and guest speaker presentations. The course encourages analytical integration of theory and its application to understanding real world events. Students do not develop a business plan.

You may access the course syllabus, lecture overheads, discussion guides, and sample exams through the Sociology Department's Web page at http://www.soc.duke.edu/courses/soc159/159syls00.html. The names of course materials are noted on the syllabus in bold capital letters and they correspond to file names on the Web site. It is recommended that students access these materials. Please contact the teaching assistant if you need assistance accessing the web site.

This course is one of the core courses in the Markets and Management certificate program. Although there are no prerequisites, and typically the course recruits students from many majors, it is assumed that students are able to understand business press articles. The two texts listed below have a glossary of terms and an index that may be useful. They are on reserve at Perkins Library.


Required Readings

The following two books are required reading and are available from the university bookstore.

Readings for this course have been drawn from a variety of books, academic journals, and the business press. They are available on reserve at Perkins Library, both on-line and in hard copy. They can be accessed rom the following web address http://www.lib.duke.edu/access/reserves. The readings also are available in the Markets and Management Program Resource Room (W9. 256) in hard copy.


Requirements

multiple choice exam 1 25%
essay exam 1 25%
multiple choice exam 2 25%
essay exam 2 25%

There are two types of exams, in class multiple choice and take home essay formats. You will have a choice of which essay questions you answer. Exam questions require students to interpret and integrate insights from theoretical readings, class lectures, and guest speaker presentations. The teaching assistant participates in grading both the multiple choice and the essay exams. Sample essay exams are available for review on the course web site, click on EF159S.96

We also may have extra credit assignments. Given the availability of speaker telephone technology, we may be able to actively hear from and engage guest speakers in question and comment sessions. These assignments will be in the form of students submitting names of potential guest speakers and in participating in the formulation and presentation of interview questions.

Prepared and active attendance is noticed and welcome. Student questions, comments and suggestions improve teaching and enhance learning for all.


Class Outline and Assignments

A) Introduction and Overview

1. W 1/12 Different approaches to the study of entrepreneurship
SYLLABUS.S94 BKGROUND FRAMWORK ENTREPRE.KV THINK

 

B) Supply Side Perspectives

This section of the course will examine theories of entrepreneurship that emphasize personal, social, and cultural background characteristics of individuals.

 
2. M 1/17 Holiday: Martin Luther King Day
3. W 1/19

Guilder (1984) "A Patch of Sand" The Spirit of Enterprise 23-41.
(Discussion: student groups will be asked to discuss the case of Jack Simplot. Was his success due to his personality, socialization, or the environment?)

guest speaker: Sharon Flynn, President of DUNE (Duke University Network of Entrepreneurs) DUNE.duke.edu

4. M 1/24

Brockhaus and Horwitz (1986) "The Psychology of the Entrepreneur" in The Art and Science of Entrepreneurship 25-44
PSYCH

guest speaker: Evan Jones, Founder and former CEO, TSI Soccer
www.gogreenlight.com

Culture as an Engine of Entrepreneurship
5. W 1/26 Weber (1930) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism 35-183
(see discussion guide)
WEBER
HYPOTH
6. M 1/31 guest speaker: Christy Jones, Founder and CEO, PC Order, spin-off of Trilogy Inc.
E-commerce company
www.trilogy.com

Christina C. Jones President and Founder, pcOrder

Christina Jones is president and founder of pcOrder, the leading provider of Internet-based electronic commerce solutions that enable the computer industry's suppliers, resellers, and end-users to buy and sell computer products online.

Jones launched pcOrder in June 1996 as a spin-off from Trilogy, the company she co-founded as a Stanford University student in 1989. Trilogy is a leading provider of sales, marketing, and business-to-business electronic commerce applications for Fortune 500 companies. While at Trilogy, Jones worked to create partnerships with many of the key members of the computer industry and in the process, discovered an enormous business opportunity. Companies within the computer industry needed a way to efficiently exchange information and conduct transactions; Jones answered with pcOrder. Today, leading computer manufacturers, distributors, corporate resellers, VARS, and retailers use pcOrder technology and services to power their own e-commerce solutions, leveraging the Internet to drive profit, cut costs, and better connect with their customers.

As president, Jones has secured major members of the computer industry as partners and customers and has led pcOrder to its position as the recognized industry standard for buying and selling computer products over the Internet.

Jones, 30, is an established leader in the computer industry. Forbes has featured Jones on three covers, most recently for her success in moving the indirect distribution channel for computers to the Internet. Jones was recently named the "1999 National Ernst and Young Entrepreneur Of The Yearâ in the Young Entrepreneur category. Jones was also named one of Computer Reseller News "1999 Top 25 Executives" and a member of the "Top 100" by Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Jones has also been named a "Web Innovator" by Information Week and one of the "Top 20 Leaders Under 30" by Working Woman. She was also presented with the Business Journal's 1999 Profiles in Power award.

A graduate of Stanford University in Palo Alto, CA., Jones received a BA in economics in 1991.

C) Demand Side PerspectivesThis section of the course examines organizational, economic, political, and societal conditions that give rise to entrepreneurship.

Culture as an Engine of Entrepreneurship

7. W 2/2 Meyer (1994) "Rationalized Environments" in Institutional Environments and Organizations by W. Richard Scott and John W. Meyer
"Come Home, Little Startups," BusinessWeek , Feb 26, 1996
(lecture and discussion: The Macro Culture as the Engine of Entrepreneurial Activity)
ENTREACT.1
SYMBOL
Hierarchies: as an Engine of Entrepreneurship
8. M 2/7 Chandler (1992) "The Emergence of Managerial Capitalism," in The Sociology of Economic Life by Mark Granovetter and Richard Swedberg
USTRUCTURE
MSTRUCTURE
9. W 2/9

Block and MacMillan (1993) "Corporate Venturing: What is it? Why do it? What is its Track Record? in Corporate Venturing: Creating New Businesses within the Firm 13-32

Mamis (1993) "The Apple Tree" Inc. August 1993

(lecture and video: How do Organizations Spawn Entrepreneurs and New Businesses? Intrapreneurship in the 3M Corporation)

(excerpt from In Search of Excellence video)

MFORM
MFORM.MF
FORM.UF

10. M 2/14

guest speaker: Dr. Robert Freese, Founder, division of 3M, Founder and former CEO Alphatronix

11. W 2/16 In class multiple choice exam 1 (material on psychology, culture, hierarchies)

Markets: as an Engine of Entrepreneurship

Markets for Companies

 
12. M 2/21

An Organizational Field Perspective
Thornton (1995) "Accounting for Acquisition Waves: Evidence from the U.S. College Publishing Industry," in The Institutional Construction of Organizations: International and Longitudinal Studies by W. Richard Scott and Soren Christensen
MWAVE
MWAVE1
EXPAND

Review multiple choice exam 1

13. W 2/23 A Managerial Perspective
Lazonick (1992) "Controlling the Market for Corporate Control: The Historical Significance Managerial Capitalism" in Industrial and Corporate Change 445-488.
Markets for Capital
14. M 2/28 Venture Capital: Dougherty, Dennis, J. 1995. "Venturing Forth: Selective Venture Capital Funds Provide the Spur of Success to Many Young Companies."

guest speaker: Mitch Mumma, Intersouth Partners, Past President, Council for Entrepreneurial Development
venture capital firm
www.intersouth.com
15. W 3/1

Forms of Investment Banking: Initial Public Offering (IPO), Leveraged Buy-Out by Management (LBO), Acquisition, and Private Placement
"IPO Capitalism" BusinessWeek, 12-18-1995
IBCASES

guest speaker: Gregory Montgomery, Managing Director, Centura Capital Investments

Networks: as an Engine of Entrepreneurship

Social Capital of Individuals
16. M 3/6 Burt (1992) Structural Holes: The Social Structure of Competition pp 8-49


Take-home exam 1 questions handed out in class, due on or before Friday 3/10 5:00 p.m., room 265, late exams are downgraded (material on psychlogy, culture, hierarchies, markets)

Incubators: Social and Political Structures

17. W 3/8

Schoonhoven and Eisenhardt (1992) "Entrepreneurial Environments: Incubator Region Effects on the Birth of New Technology-Based Firms," in High Technology Ventures by L. Gomez-Mejia & M. Lawless.

Campbell and Lindberg (1990) "Property Rights and the Organization of Economic Activity" ASR 634-644

(lecture: The Role of Social and Political Structure in Creating Incubator Regions for New Investment)

18. M 3/13 Spring Break
19. W 3/15 Spring Break
20. M 3/20

Guest Speaker: Paul Mayer, Founder and CEO, Fusion Ventures
Incubator firm
www.fusionventures.com

D) Entrepreneurship in Industries and Organizational Populations and Fields This section of the course will consider how competition, cooperation, and technological innovation affect how and where new enterprise is likely to arise and the strategies that firms are likely to employ.

Competitive Perspectives: Population Ecology and Industrial Economics

21. W 3/22

Aldrich and Wiedenmayer (1993) "From Traits to Rates: An Ecological Perspective on Organizational Foundings" Advances in Entrepreneurship Firm Emergence and Growth 145- 195

Telephone interview with Bobbi Brown, founder and CEO Bobbi Brown Cosmetics

POPECOL
POPECOL.WO
POPECOL.D

22. M 3/27

Porter (1980) "The Structural Analysis of Industries" Competitive Strategy 3-33(lecture: Competitive Dynamics at the Industry Level)
PORTER.CF,
PORTER.BE,
PORTER.R,
PORTER.EB,
PORTER.CS,
PORTER.CF1,
PORTER.BP

Cooperative and Technological Perspectives
23. W 3/29

Arthur (1990) "Positive Feedbacks in the Economy" Scientific American Feb. 92-99 Technological Innovation

Tushman and Anderson (1986) "Technological discontinuities and Organizational Environments." ASQ 31: 439-465.
24. M 4/3

In class multiple choice exam 2 (material on markets, networks, section D)

 

E) Organizational Creation and Change. This section of the course examines how to create an effective organization that is enduring and adaptable.

Leadership: An Institutional Perspective, Organizations as Organic Structures

 

25. W 4/5

Selznick (1957) Leadership in Administration 1-64
(video and discussion: Henry VI and the speech before battle--institutionalizing meaning and purpose)
SELZNICK.IT
T/I ENVIR

Review multiple choice exam 2

 

26. M 4/10 Selznick (1957) Leadership in Administration 65-154
(lecture: Defining the Mission Statement and the Role of Leadership in Creating an Enduring Organization)
SELZNICK.MS
SELZNICK.MS1
27. W 4/12

guest speaker: student selected telephone speaker

 

Internal Perspectives on Organizational Culture

 

28. M 4/17

J. Martin (1992) "Seeing Cultures from Different Points of View" Cultures in Organizations: Three Perspectives 3-21

Van Maanen and Kunda (1991) "The Smile Factory: Work at Disneyland" Reframing Organizational Culture 58-75 (video: "In Search of Excellence: the Disney Corporation" ) (lecture and discussion: Formal and Informal Organization and Aspects of Social Structure that Affect Adherence to Corporate Culture)
SELZNICK.AC
CULTURE.JM

Internal and External Perspectives: Linking Management Decision Making to the Wider Cultural Context
29. W 4/19

Dumaine (1993) "The Work Place/Cover Story" Fortune 39-41
Barley and Kunda (1992) "Design and Devotion: Surges of Rational and Normative Ideologies of Control in Managerial Discourse" ASQ 363-399

Telephone interview with Jeff Bezos, founder and CEO Amazon.com

(video: Apple as an "In Search of Excellence" corporation and the role of culture as an organizing strategy)
(discussion: external origins of corporate culture and management strategy)

Design and Change of Established Organizations
30. M 4/24

Greiner (1972) "Evolution and Revolution as Organizations Grow" Harvard Business Review 37-46

Chesbrough and Teece (1996) "When is Virtual Virtuous?," Harvard Business Review

31. W 4/26 Thornton (1999) "The Sociology of Entrepreneurship," Annual Review of SociologyReview and Conclusion
Course Evaluation
REVIEW
Take-home essay exam 2 questions handed-out in class, due at the end of the hour of the final exam in my office room 265. Exam may draw upon all course material. Late exams are down graded. Exam questions may be completed early and slipped under my office door in room 265 bldg. 9. I cannot verify receipt of faxed exams.